Beachfront Development along the Pacific Coast of Colombia: A good thing? By Orrin H. Pilkey & William J. Neal

Posted In Beach of the Month, Features

By Orrin H. Pilkey and William J. Neal

Although it seems to defy logic, building a home right next to an eroding beach may be a good idea in some cases.

When the two of us, along with Jaime Martinez and Juan Gonzalez, were studying the Colombia’s Pacific Coast barrier islands, we visited a couple of small villages perched on the edge of rapidly eroding beaches (Martinez, et al., 1995). In one instance we watched as a house was being dismantled to be moved back. Local people told us that two men could dismantle and move most of the village houses in a matter of weeks (figure 1). At the time, they were keeping the village in the retreating back-beach position, yielding to beach retreat of a few meters per month due to extra high spring tides during an El Niño (figures 2 and 3).

We described the nature of these beautiful tropical beaches in our August 1, 2011, Beach-of-the-Month article.

Although there is a good sand supply coming via rivers from the nearby Andes Mountains, a combination of high wave energy, sea level rise due to global climate change, regional effects of seismic activity and El Niños, and local subsidence, cause beach retreat (shoreline transgression).

… At first the high-risk location of these villages didn’t make any sense to us. Why should the locals live so dangerously?”
—Orrin H. Pilkey and William J. Neal

The black to dark gray sandy beaches are littered with fallen trees, drift wood, and wrack lines of flotsam. Stands of mangrove forest that grew behind barrier beaches are now dead or dying (Figure 4).

At first the high-risk location of these villages didn’t make any sense to us. Why should the locals live so dangerously?

After a few days, however, we began to understand. Living in such a remote area, the villagers had no means of communication with the outside world, no phones, and no radios. The law and medical help were a long way away. Malaria-transmitting mosquitoes inhabit the nearby rain forest.

Ivan Correa and Juan Gonzalez summed up the reasons for such village sites in their 2000 article.

• The villagers know at any time the sea and weather conditions, in order to plan activities.

• The possibility exists of having eye contact with fishing teams at a short distance offshore (in dugout canoes).

• Being aware of travelers along the coast allows villagers to be able to provide or to demand
assistance in an emergency, especially useful because of the lack of radios.

• A minimum tourist infrastructure had been developed as a source of income, an important
alternative, considering that the two main economic activities, fishing and timber, were
becoming increasingly difficult.

• Directly facing the sea takes advantage of the sea breeze for a more comfortable climate and
especially to keep malaria-transmitting mosquitoes away.

Erosion rates along this coast are sporadic. Periods of stability of a few years are followed by catastrophic erosion and/or transgression rates resulting from earthquakes on the adjacent continental shelf (e.g., Tumaco, 1979) (See Correa and Morton, 2010, for a review of Colombia’s Pacific Coast). On Soldado Island along the central portion of the coast, we found that local sea level rise could be as high as 10 feet per century. As noted above, times of El Niño also accelerate the erosion rate.

Different strokes for different folks. In the remote Pacific coast of Colombia, beachfront development has been a necessity. But even there in a subsistence economy that depends on being next to the sea, the rising sea level is changing this option. As Correa and Gonzalez note, the village of El Choncho that had persisted for 91 years, being moved laterally or back from the retreating beach as necessary, finally had to move inland to a higher elevation in 1997. The move, however, was facilitated by the fact that all of the dwellings were built in such a way that they could be easily disassembled and reconstructed in a short period of time, and at a low cost.

… In a time of rising sea level we can only view such beachfront development as imprudent and irresponsible.”
—Orrin H. Pilkey and William J. Neal

Not so in the first world where beachfront development is placed in high-risk zones by choice, rather than necessity, and increasingly using construction that does not favor being easily moved out of harm’s of way in the future.

Even though widespread awareness of the importance of impending sea level rise is only a couple of decades old, post WWII beachfront development in the first world usually took place on shorelines that were clearly retreating.

In a time of rising sea level we can only view such beachfront development as imprudent and irresponsible.

Correa, Ivan D. and Gonzalez, Juan Luis, 2000, Coastal Erosion and Village relocation: A Colombian case study: Ocean and Coastal Management, 51 – 64.

Correa, I. D., and Morton, R. A., 2010, Coasts of Colombia: U. S. Geological Survey.

Martinez,J., Gonzalez J., Pilkey, O.H. and Neal W.J, 1995, Tropical Barrier Islands of Colombia’s Pacific Coast: Journal of Coastal Research, 432 – 453.

Colombian Pacific Beaches at the Mouth of Bahia de Buenaventura, By Orrin H. Pilkey and William J. Neal
Among the world’s most remote beaches are those that line the 62 barrier islands of Colombia’s Pacific Coast. Only two roads lead over the Andes to access points from which the islands and their few, very small, subsistence coastal villages can be reached by boat.


More / Beach Of The Month

Torrevieja, Spain; By Norma J. Longo

January 1st, 2018

Torrevieja, a former fishing village on the southeast coast of Spain (Costa Blanca) in Alicante province, is now a thriving tourist city with a 2016 population of around 85,000, down from a high of over 105,000 in 2013.

Read More

The rugged coast and black sand beaches of the Azores; By Gary Griggs

December 1st, 2017

A soft, white sandy beach on a lush green island is probably the vision many people have of their perfect coastal vacation. Eight hundred and fifty miles west of Portugal and 2400 miles east of Boston lies the lush island of São Miguel in the Azores. It is one of nine islands making up an archipelago spread across 300 miles of the North Atlantic Ocean.

Read More

Colombia’s Tayrona National Natural Park: A Caribbean Coast Gem; By Nelson Rangel-Buitrago & William J. Neal

October 1st, 2017

Colombia’s Caribbean coast has a rich geological, biological and cultural diversity that is reflected in the complex coastal zone extending from the border of Panama to that of Venezuela. One of the most spectacular regions in both this diversity and scenery is the Tayrona National Natural Park (TNNP).

Read More

The end of the world’s most famous beaches; By Orrin H. Pilkey and J. Andrew G. Cooper

August 1st, 2017

All over the world there are beaches lined with condos, hotels, restaurants and the like, in high-rise buildings (i.e., skyscrapers). Such beaches are generally the nation’s premier tourist areas, important to the local people and the local economy and prime spots for national and international vacationers. The powers that be in most of these places continue high-rise construction and seem oblivious of the sea level rise.

Read More

The natural bridges of Santa Cruz County; By Gary Griggs

June 1st, 2017

While most coastlines often appear to be stable and permanent over the short time span of our visits, and some are, there are many others where the materials making up the coastal bluffs or cliffs are no match for the forces the sea exerts…Over time, the ocean always wins. In baseball terms, Mother Nature always bats last.

Read More

Sandbagging at the Shore: North Carolina’s Coastal Sand Bags and Political Sandbaggers; By William Neal, Orrin Pilkey & Norma Longo

April 1st, 2017

The wonder of modern English is how social use of language expands and changes the meaning of words. Sand bag is a bag filled with sand used for temporary construction—quickly made, easily transported, and easily removed. Typically, sandbagging is the emplacement of sand bags to construct a temporary protective wall or barrier, such as a dike or dam to hold back flood waters , or protection on the battlefield. But the term ‘sandbagging’ has taken on an array of other meanings…

Read More

Englands’ Jurassic Coast; By Gary Griggs

February 1st, 2017

In 2001, ninety-six miles of the south coast of England along the English Channel was designated as a World Heritage Site. This picturesque stretch of cliffs and beaches extends from Exmouth on the east to Studland Bay on the west.

Read More

Beach cusps: shoreline symmetry; By Gary Griggs

December 1st, 2016

There are many strikingly regular patterns in nature that have long intrigued scientists and non-scientists alike. Beach cusps are one of these.

Read More

Archive / Beach Of The Month